‘1 Samuel actually suggests that, from a man’s point of view, a woman with a happy marriage need not be distraught about not having any children. Hannah’s situation made her very unhappy, especially at the time of the annual sacri?ce, when she would cry and would not eat.
Elkanah’s reaction to Hannah’s unhappiness is worth noting: “Hannah, why do you weep? Why do you not eat? Why is your heart sad? Am I not more to you than ten sons?”? This is hardly the response of a patriarch who can see value in women only as childbearers and implies the possibility of a relationship in which love was more important than childbearing.
It should be noted, however, that Elkanah was not himself childless. His society gave him the opportunity, and he was apparently able to afford, to have both a wife to love and a wife to make children. Since he had already ?lled his need for a family to remember and honor him (the only kind of “immortality” known to these narratives), his lack of understanding for Hannah’s unhappiness begins to look less sentimental and more naive or even insensitive.
Hannah, for her part, while she may have loved her husband, still needed children, and not only for her personal emotional ful?llment. In her society a woman’s prestige was based at least partly on her demonstrated ability to produce offspring. It was in such a situation that Peninnah could torment her.
To the narrator, and presumably his audience, childlessness was not understood as a physical phenomenon, but as a decision of God – and, indeed, in some instances as a punishment from God (see Genesis 20).
Hannah seems to agree with this understanding and takes her case directly to Yahweh. If it is Yahweh who ”closed her womb,” only Yahweh can give her children. She goes to the temple and vows that if Yahweh will give her a son, she will, in effect, give him back to Yahweh as a temple servant. This vow is in itself telling: far from wanting a child for emotional comfort, she is offering to forgo the pleasure of having him with her while he is growing up. She seems simply to want to give birth to a son.
It is possible to take another view of Hannah’s vow, however, that is perhaps more nuanced. In Israel one gave the ?rstfruits of animals and of the harvest to Yahweh, probably in hopes of receiving in return the blessing of continued fertility…. ?If Hannah’s offer to dedicate her ?rstborn to Yahweh can be seen in this light, her motives are more complex. She does not simply desire the societal status and relief from rival-wife torment that bearing a son would bring but also “offers up” her ?rstborn to Yahweh in hopes of receiving more children in return.
… And this is what happens: Hannah bears three sons and two daughters.’
Women’s Bible Commentary, Carol A. Newsom and Sharon H. Ringe Eds., John Knox Press, Louisville, 1992, p.95-96.